Violence And Discontented Youth - Neglected Children Act Out
Posted: Friday, August 26, 2011
by Jennifer Stewart
Stepping out of History
Who says the British aren’t emotional and passionate? Shortly after the riots in England I saw a man interviewed on BBC whose restaurant had been destroyed by out-of-control kids. I really felt for him; he had ploughed his everything into that restaurant and now he had nothing. He was so angry, and who could blame him? He’d always worked hard, taking responsibility for himself and for the people he employed. He deserved his success. My heart went out to him.
There’s never any justification for this kind of seemingly senseless and vicious looting. The bunch of hoodies who approached that young boy who was wounded, pretending to help him while they picked his pocket – it revolts everything in me. The thing is, looking for or denying justification is absolutely useless, it doesn’t help anybody.
This explosion of violence happened and nothing ever happens without a reason. To pin it on reckless, irresponsible youth who just want something for nothing and to say this isn’t about poverty or disenfranchisement is so short-sighted. Of course it’s about disenfranchisement and what it does to the core of a person over generations. You can’t know, unless you’ve experienced it, what it is to be disempowered.
So often people who come from a middle-class or better social set-up don’t realize how much inner strength that has given them. How can they? They’ve got no personal experience to compare it to. All the rational explanations about being responsible that people from this sector of society love to apply to criminals’ behavior don’t amount to a hill of beans.
Disempowerment creates ravaged self-esteem. Combine that with over-permissive entitlement and the frustration of not being able to go anywhere with your life and your dreams; add the deep anger and grief that results from not being loved and cared for and given opportunities and you’ve got combustion waiting to happen. Surely the pot has been simmering for a long time and everybody has been hoping it would somehow remain “not my business”.
I appreciated how both BBC and CNN interviewed people who had depth of insight into the problem and understood that there’s no quick fix and that moralizing isn’t going to help anybody. I think a society has the right to require its citizens to behave with integrity towards each other and to respect each other’s property, and I also think those kids have to face the reality of how much they’ve hurt people and to take responsibility for their actions.
But it’s a harsh lesson for a child to have to learn. They already have so little within themselves. What they really need is love and protection and care and the kind of discipline that comes from nurturing and healthy parenting, not punishment. I think about all the money that gets spent on arms and warfare by Britain. If that was spent on the disenfranchised children, within a generation England would be a totally different place.
As adults we neglect the children of our world and then we expect them to be responsible. Why should they? We aren’t.
This explosion of violence happened and nothing ever happens without a reason. To pin it on reckless, irresponsible youth who just want something for nothing and to say this isn’t about poverty or disenfranchisement is so short-sighted. Of course it’s about disenfranchisement and what it does to the core of a person over generations. You can’t know, unless you’ve experienced it, what it is to be disempowered.
So often people who come from a middle-class or better social set-up don’t realize how much inner strength that has given them. How can they? They’ve got no personal experience to compare it to. All the rational explanations about being responsible that people from this sector of society love to apply to criminals’ behavior don’t amount to a hill of beans.
Disempowerment creates ravaged self-esteem. Combine that with over-permissive entitlement and the frustration of not being able to go anywhere with your life and your dreams; add the deep anger and grief that results from not being loved and cared for and given opportunities and you’ve got combustion waiting to happen. Surely the pot has been simmering for a long time and everybody has been hoping it would somehow remain “not my business”.
I appreciated how both BBC and CNN interviewed people who had depth of insight into the problem and understood that there’s no quick fix and that moralizing isn’t going to help anybody. I think a society has the right to require its citizens to behave with integrity towards each other and to respect each other’s property, and I also think those kids have to face the reality of how much they’ve hurt people and to take responsibility for their actions.
But it’s a harsh lesson for a child to have to learn. They already have so little within themselves. What they really need is love and protection and care and the kind of discipline that comes from nurturing and healthy parenting, not punishment. I think about all the money that gets spent on arms and warfare by Britain. If that was spent on the disenfranchised children, within a generation England would be a totally different place.
As adults we neglect the children of our world and then we expect them to be responsible. Why should they? We aren’t.
This Article has been viewed 485 times. (Not updated in real-time.)
Top-level comments on this article: (6 total)An awful lot of money is already spent on them. thanks for the essay.
Well thanks for commenting, Jack. We can agree to disagree, right?!
Hi Jennifer.
I also saw a lot of what Gregory saw, growing up in Los Angeles County. It was very scary and very hard to understand. We were poor, but my parents grew up poor in a time when the "poor farmer" was the excepted norm and so we never thought anything about not having as much as the people around us did. So for me, I was one of those people who just couldn't understand what made rioters think it was okay to do that and to loot stores.
You've made that a little more understandable for me. I don't see an end to the problem really, though. No matter how much money you throw at it. As long as there are people who have more, there will be those who have less. How do you teach them to be satisfied with what they have? How do you get across the concept of self-worth as divorced from possessions when all the rest of society seems to be telling you otherwise? Argh!
Great article!
Hugs,
DianneIt's very hard to solve that problem, isn't it. There's so much permissiveness now and I think when it's coupled with low self-esteem it's lethal. Maybe I'm naive, but I think the only hope is to find a way to touch their hearts and provide good boundaries and a way to express safely and be heard. Easily said, but not so easily done.
Kids need role models - even if it is a neighbor, aunt, uncle, teacher etc.Amen, Marijo.
The haves and have-nots have always existed in this world- it's the duality of life again. For every poor and disenfranchised person who goes out to loot burn and steal- there is one from the same background who does not. I think it's teaching and example that can make the difference. Interesting and thoughtful article Jenn. Always Ella
I think so too, Ella.
We want your comments! If you can read this, you don't have javascript enabled, so you can't use this comment system. Please enable javascript.




