Jennifer Stewart

When Emotions are Strong, Judgment is Easy, Truth is Hard to Face


Posted: Friday, November 11, 2011

by Jennifer Stewart
Stepping out of History

Truth.  There was a time when I thought it was always a black and white thing.  I was wrong, it isn’t.  There’s truth within a logical or mathematical system, like one and one equals two.  Or it’s conditional - a four-legged table won’t stand on its own if one of the legs are removed, depending where the legs are and how heavy the table top is.

But between people?  It’s way more complicated.  I can come into group of people and believe everybody is avoiding the truth, but what truth am I thinking of?  The truth of what I can see?  How do I know that what I can see isn’t just a projection of my own unresolved issues?  One thing I know is that when I make a judgment about them there’s definitely unresolved stuff in me.  I judge them so I don’t have to look at me - because it’s too painful.

I used to be so sure of myself in what I saw in other people, because emotions are clear to me.  I see them like people see colors.  It makes a group of people confusing for me because all the emotions are flying around at one level, but often it seems to me that they’re not being acknowledged, so there’s a whole other level at which people are interacting.  Sometimes it’s like a swarm of giant bees in the room.

The mistake I made was in thinking I understood what motivated people to do the things they did, and understanding the why of their emotions.  I can see now that I can’t know that.  I can speculate, but my speculation won’t amount to a hill of useless beans.

Useless being the operative word.  I don’t even always know it for myself.  In fact judging by how many times I’ve thought I did know, only to realize later on there was more to learn, I can never know the whole why of anything I do at any given moment.  So I definitely can’t know it about other people.

So where does truth between people lie, especially if I’m in a relationship with somebody and some kind of behavior results in me being hurt?  Maybe the only thing I can be sure of is how I feel and what I need.  Hold myself away from judgment of them altogether, because all my judgment does is hurt them and possibly provoke anger.

If they get angry I’ve got the option of saying they’re a trouble-maker and judging them even more, refusing to take responsibility for my original judgment.  But where’s that going to get me?  Absolutely nowhere.  I might feel righteous, but it will be at their expense.

It’s passive aggression.  I can kick you and get away with it, make it look like it’s your fault. I think we all do this at different times.  It’s the way our culture operates, it thrives on judgment and avoiding our emotions and our own truth.  I know I’ve done it a lot and I still do.  It’s a seductive thing because my truth can be excruciatingly painful.  But hard as it is to accept, it doesn’t achieve anything - for me or anybody else.

What if I’m amongst a group where everybody is in denial, where a lot of emotions are flying around and everybody’s too scared to express them?  Must I just swallow my frustration?  Walk
Must I just swallow my frustration? Absolutely not. I'll just achieve more if I say 'I feel' and 'I need' instead of condemning you
away?   Absolutely not.  I have the right to say what I want to say.  I’ll just achieve more for me if I can take responsibility for my own emotions and say I feel and I need instead of condemning you and saying it's all your fault.

Truth between people?  It’s hard.  My truth isn’t going to be the same as your truth.  It’s definitely not black and white.  Life isn’t black and white.  Everything happens in the grey area.  So is what I’ve said here the penultimate truth?  No.  It’s just mine.  And I have no doubt it will evolve, if I let it.
Jennifer Stewart is the author of ebook And What About Me? Am I Into Him?

After a life of being adaptive, Jennifer is starting to do it her way. She values independence of mind and spirit and treasures the gift of being able to walk her own path and make dreams come true.

Right now she is now working on a crime novel, a memoire and three film scripts. She also plays piano and sings jazz standards and has a blog at And What About Me?

This Article has been viewed 352 times. (Not updated in real-time.)
Top-level comments on this article: (4 total)
» left by Jack H. Schick 191 days 16 hours ago.
99 fans.
As a Quaker, I cannot accept that there is other than one truth. I cannot permit myself to form a judgment of other people, either. I can recognize and accept dishonesty in others, but it is within myself that I look for universal truth, to the Light that is in each of us. Those who do not see and expose the one Truth are simply not in harmony with the spirit. It is not my responsibility to point out the spirit. They too must seek it within.
» left by Jennifer Stewart 187 days ago.
153 fans.
I also believe there is a fundamental truth in the spirit of life.
» left by Hilda Cang
191 days 10 hours ago.
60 fans.
Sometimes, truth is being buried 6' underground and never will be revealed. I do not want very much the truth of other people for it's unknown to me and what's more, perhaps they find me just as unpredictable and mysterious. (LOL)
» left by Jennifer Stewart 187 days ago.
153 fans.
I think you're very sensible, Hilda :)
» left by Christofer French
188 days 17 hours ago.
74 fans.
Difficult topic and you handled it with aplomb. Your usual sincerity came through in spades. Thanks for your wonderful article.
» left by Jennifer Stewart 187 days ago.
153 fans.
And you always write such great comments, Christofer, thanks!
» left by Tharuna Devchand
187 days 4 hours ago.
16 fans. Follow Tharuna Devchand on twitter!
Does truth really matter though? In the larger scheme of things. We all have our own truths, some most honest than others. But do those truths matter to other people. Does every aspect that makes us us mean anything to anyone other than ourselves?

Explanations and justifications are constantly seen as ways to manipulate someone... to change their mind rather than to clear the air. We live in a world where people are allowed to have open opinions about everything that they begin to think that their opinions are truth because they repeat it so often. Everything is judged by assumption and not truth. From people to court cases to news... its the closet possibility of the truth from one or a number of peoples perspectives.

I dont believe in the truth for the same reason that I dont believe that that dude in the Lotter case is possessed... People! Everything we know, everything thing we follow, even our own thoughts are from the hands of humanity... And you cant trust people cos people are swayed by their motives and experiences and perspectives.

So there, i believe that truth does not exist.
» left by Jennifer Stewart 187 days ago.
153 fans.
I was talking about this in therapy today! I think it is possible for our truths to matter to others. That's what love is. We care about each other's experience and we want to know. We don't want to judge.

I agree that we're all swayed by experience and how that's contributed to forming our beliefs etc. We've all got filters. But I think people who are willing to face and deal with their own crap are ultimately trustworthy. For me trust isn't about a person not reacting to me, it's about that person being self-aware.

» left by Tharuna Devchand
186 days 20 hours ago.
16 fans. Follow Tharuna Devchand on twitter!
I never thought about it that way...
We want your comments! If you can read this, you don't have javascript enabled, so you can't use this comment system. Please enable javascript.